Delayed Justice

Judging is supposed to be a very careful process. In binding over Aurelias J. Marshall for the murder of Christopher Joel Battaglia, 61st District Court Judge Michael Christensen displays the care by which he reached his conclusion. This, along with comments from Gail and Jerry Battaglia make up this segment.

Judge Christensen binds over A.J. Marshall from David Schock on Vimeo.

Christensen, who retired last fall, was back on the bench to finish up matters he had started in this case. Another judge in the courthouse described him as both meticulous and gifted…a really, really good judge. This video clip is a look into the process of what he took into account, weighing evidence from all the witnesses. In doing so, he steered a very fine line among and between confluent and conflicting testimonies. We had two people who testified they were eye Witnesses: Sheila Reed, and Aurelias’ brother, Acey, and their stories differed in significant ways. But both were in agreement when said they watched Aurelias Marshall “beat down” Joel Battaglia in the early morning attack on Lake Drive. And both brothers told others what they had done and seen so there was support.

Aurelias Marshall waived his arraignment in circuit court and is headed for trial. I would suppose there will be motion hearings and the trial is likely to be some time away.

And you all might be wondering where my confirmation of all that is.

If you haven’t otherwise read it, get started here, with John Tunison’s account of Tuesday’s preliminary hearing.

Here is some of Acey Marshall’s testimony of watching his brother, Aurelias (A.J.) Marshall, and Malcolm Jeffries beat Christopher Joel Battaglia to death June 11, 1990. Jeffries has so far been charged only with perjury.

Acey Marshall testimony at prelim from David Schock on Vimeo.

THere is so much more. Tomorrow I will load up 61st Circuit Court Judge Michael Christensen’s ruling binding A.J. Marshall over to stand trial.

Just a reminder that the preliminary hearing is for the purpose of convincing a District Court Judge that there is reason to believe that the accused could have committed the crime. If there is enough evidence to believe it possible, the District Court judge, in this case 61st District Court Judge Michael Christensen (retired), will then bind over the accused, in this case Aurelias (A.J.) Marshall, for arraignment in Circuit Court. From there the possibilities include a dismissal of charges, a plea, or a trial.

In Friday’s prelim in the matter of the beating death of Christopher Joel Battaglia we heard first from the officer who responded to the scene, Officer Roland Sherman (retired). He checked for a pulse and found none, but paramedics transported Joel to the hospital where he was pronounced. Sherman described the efforts, finally successful, at identifying Joel (apparently, he had been robbed of his wallet) by the tattoo of a phoenix on the right ankle.

The next witness was Sheila Marie Reed, who lived directly across the street from the assault (which was at 1065 Lake Drive). Under direct examination by Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Kellee Koncki,she finally admitted–after 24-plus years of denying it–that she was an eye witness to the crime and knew the assailant on sight (they worked together at the 28th Street Holiday Inn). This is some of her testimony:

Prelim Sheila Reed from David Schock on Vimeo.

Joel’s father, Jerry, does not recall Ms. Reed as being welcoming; if anything she was hostile at the time. It was Ms. Reed’s mother, in fact, who urged her daughter to speak with them.

Yes, Ms. Reed admitted under cross examination by defense attorney Charlie Clapp, that she has a distant history as a crack user, was a sometime dealer, has had a stroke, and a mental breakdown, but remained firm in her assertion that she watched A.J. Marshall beat someone in the early morning hours of June 11, 1990.

Finally, we heard from Guadalupe (Lupe) Harwood, a neighbor of A.J. Marshall’s, who said that Marshall once described to him an assault on a young white man, a beating which Harwood said Marshall acknowledged was undertaken with his brother (that would be Acey Marshall, also arrested on a felony perjury charge, as was Malcolm Xavier Jeffries and Reed).

The preliminary hearing will resume on Tuesday at 8:30 a.m. in courtroom 8A of the Kent County Courthouse.

Here is Barton Deiters’ report in the Grand Rapids Press.

Retired 61st District Court Judge Michael Christensen will make a return to the bench tomorrow for the preliminary hearing for accused murderer Aurelias Jualious (A.J.) Marshall, 56, of Grand Rapids. Marshall faces open murder charges and felony perjury in the June 11, 1990, beating death of 23-year-old Christopher Joel Battaglia as Battaglia walked along Lake Drive near the border between East Hills and Easttown in Grand Rapids.

So far A.J. Marshall is the sole individual charged with murder although three others, including his brother Acey Marshall, are charged with felony perjury, potentially life offenses. The other two are Sheila Reed, who lived across the street from the scene of the murder, and Malcolm Xavier Jeffries.

It will be most interesting to see whether any of the three will testify either tomorrow or next week, when the preliminary is set to continue.

I will be there with my camera; I’ve been granted access. And if you are looking for video tomorrow…you’ll have to wait until I can get to it. Slowly, slowly on this end. It may be Saturday or Sunday.

…of Aurelias Marshall in the beating death of Joel Battaglia might begin at 8:30 a.m. next Friday. That, according to Kent County facilities management. It had been set for 1:30 p.m., but that has been changed. I will call again on the 15th to make sure; there are likely many changes that must be made to accommodate the time required for a preliminary hearing. And I have no idea if that can happen all in one day or whether it well take several days (and into the following week). We’ll just have to see.

As well, I called the Newaygo County Jail this week to see if either of the brothers’ Jones–Matthew or Paul–had bonded out. Nope. they remain incarcerated on $750,000 cash or surety for Paul and $500,000 cash or surety for Matthew (Skip).