From David — A weblog (with full archive)

March 6, 2020 — Mr. McMillan is sentenced

McMillan Sentencing from David Schock on Vimeo.

1 Comment »

March 4, 2020 — Sentencing tomorrow for Mr. McMillan

Tomorrow at 3 p.m. in Eaton County’s 56th Circult County, Judge Janice Cummingham presiding, Christopher Wayne McMillan will be sentenced for his part in the murder of Roberto Caraballo, May 7, 2002. He pled guilty last year and went on to testify against co-conspirator Dineane Ducharme. He likely will be called upon to testify against Beverly McMullen when she is returned from Rome in the (near??) future, courtesy of Federal Marshalls and the State Department. All that is part of the plea agreement that gives him only 15 years for his part in the crime. If his testimony is truthful, we understand that instead of striking Mr. Caraballo with a baseball bat–his duty as assigned by Beverly–he intentionally swung at a post in the basement and shattered the bat. He was not eager to kill and found himself in a nightmare. …And aligned with a remoreseless murderer.

I had been looking forward to being at this event to see this part of the work complete, but I will not be. I have been sidelined by another spinal fusion surgery. I can not even LIFT a camera, much less operate one. That’s for the next several months. My trusted associate Thom Bell WILL be there in my stead. I am grateful. He will make better pictures than I do. We will post them as soon as it’s possible.

No Comments, Be the First! »

February 13, 2020 — Beverly in custody!

Detective Sergeant Josh Ivey of the Eaton County Sheriff’s department told me last month that he was sure Beverly McCallum–wanted for the 2002 murder and mutilation of her husband, Roberto Caraballo–would be found. It was just a matter of time. “They don’t get away often,” he said.

He and I agreed, I taking my cue from the idea that there is nothing hidden that shall not be made known. The whereabouts of an accused killer would fall into that realm. It seemed obvious to both of us that that she would slip up and be found.

She did and she was. Here’s today’s Detroit Free Press article on the same.

She has been on the run with her teenaged son since she vanished from Pakistan. There was even a report that she had made it as far as South America. But no. Rome.

There are so many stories that will come out as she is brought back to face justice. Yes, our film Jack in the Box and this web played a significant role, but it’s the dogged determination of law enforcers who had led this case the Beverly’s apprehension and the so-far prosecution of Christopher McMillan (who pled guilty) and the binding over to face charges of first-degree murder for Beverly’s daughter Dineane Ducharme.

That part of the story starts with a phone call that Detective Bob Donker, now retired from the Ottawa County Sheriff’s Department, received in 2015.

And it’s there I’ll leave it for now. While I may know some things, just because I may be aware does mean that it’s mine to tell. There is one thing that is mine to tell: there have been so many people praying for justice in this case. So many. I believe we have just witnessed another miracle.

1 Comment »

February 6, 2020 — An arrest in the murder of Renee Pagel

Thirteen years after her murder, Renee Pagel’s husband, Michael James Pagel, has been charged with the crime. This according to WOODTV.

One of the people cited in the story is Chris Crandle, Renee’s good friend and untiring advocate for revealing the killer. Chris has remained sure right from the start that it was Michael who was responsible for Renee’s stabbing death in her home in Courtland Township, Kent County, MI, on August 5, 2006. But assurance and proof are two different things. It seems that at last they have come together. Everyone should have such a friend. Thank you, Chris. Thank you. And thank you law enforcement and Kent County Prosecutor Chris Becker for pressing on. Now it begins to play out.

Two days and two stunning revelations in delayed-justice cases.

No Comments, Be the First! »

February 5, 2020 — Dennis Bowman may have confessed to the killing of Alexis Badger/Aundria Bowman.

So much more to come but we don’t know how quickly. My understanding from the news story is that based on his admission of having killed his adopted daughter, Alexis Badger/Aundria Bowman, and revealed the location where he buried her, human remains have been found under a concrete pad on his former property.

Here is the story from WOODTV.

While the law enforcers are not saying that the remains at hers, her biological mother, Cathy Terkanian, asserts they are and that she has learned Bowman has confessed to causing her death. Law enforcement officials are not stating that much yet. They have to be very careful about what news they release and when. Bowman has a long history of assaulting women and is charged with the death of Kathleen Doyle, 25, in Norfolk, VA, in 1980. He is facing extradition.

Will this case keep him in Michigan? We’ll see. Or if he confesses to all or is convicted where will he do his time? Again, we’ll see.

Cathy Terkanian at last has the beginning of some answers.

No Comments, Be the First! »

January 7, 2020 — Mr. McMillan’s sentencing has been postponed

The sentencing for Christopher Wayne McMillan in relation to the 2002 murder of Roberto Caraballo “has been adjourned without a new date.”

The reasons could be many, including that because Dineane Ducharme, Mr. Caraballo’s step-daughter, has chosen to go to trial for her alleged part in his death, that Mr. McMillan will need to be on hand to testify. Providing truthful testimony was a part of his lesser, second-degree murder charge. He has been promised a sentence of 15 years for his complicity in the crime, the coverup and the treatment of Mr. Caraballo’s body. Ms. Ducharme now faces first degree charges, a mandatory life without parole if she is convicted. …Unless she seeks a plea.

Ms. Ducharme’s mother, Beverly McCallum, is still being sought for her role as the alleged mastermind and primary actor in the May 7, 2002 murder.

On a sidenote, January 11th will be Mr. Caraballo’s birthday.

No Comments, Be the First! »

December 4, 2019 –The expert witness of Dr. Stephen Cohle and the binding over of Dineane Ducharme

Here is yesterday’s testimony of forensic pathologist Dr. Stephen Cohle and the ruling of District Court Judge Julie Reinke that defendant Dineane Ducharme is bound over for trial in Eaton County. This testimony includes graphic evidence from 11:30 to 22:03 and is not intended for children or others who will be aggrieved by it. But the photos admitted into evidence illustrate just what his murderers did to Roberto Caraballo.

Dr. Stephen Cohle from David Schock on Vimeo.

No Comments, Be the First! »

December 3, 2019 — In court, and some background of Dennis Bowman’s arrest

Today I spent watching forensic pathologist Dr. Stephen Cohle give his expert testimony and recollections of the Jack in the Box case. The defendant, Dineane Ducharme, was bound over for trial, so the prosecutor made his case. Tomorrow I will post Dr. Cohle’s testimony and show the graphic evidence admitted, both of which helped lead to the judgement of the court. Ducharme is bound over for trial in circuit court…and unless she takes a good look at the witnesses arrayed against her and sues for a plea that might result in life as opposed to a lesser sentence. But that’s tomorrow.

But today is this, the press release issued by the Norfolk Virginia Commonwealth Attorney’s office. I urge you to ponder one phase in the description of the way the case was solved: “forensic evidence.” Good old fashioned police work and forensic evidence. More to come.

1 Comment »

November 29, 2019 — Imagine the loss

Imagine that in 1974, as a 17-year-old, you gave birth to a child in circumstances that dictated (even against your wishes) that giving that little girl up for adoption was the best plan, or at least the plan pushed by your mother. Imagine you surrendered the child when she was nine months old in 1975.

Imagine more than 35 years go by, but not a day without longing for news of your child.

Then imagine you are contacted in 2010 by law enforcement officials from the state where you surrendered her–Virginia–who contact you to ask you for a DNA sample to test against a body that had been discovered, and that, further, your daughter disappeared and has been missing for more than 20 years. Imagine the young girl she was…only 14 when she was last seen March 11, 1989.

Imagine that you also learn some of the history, that your daughter had been adopted when she was two years old, in 1976, by a couple then living in Virginia. And imagine that you learn that subsequently she and her family moved to west Michigan and that her adoptive father had been arrested there and charged with the attempted murder of another young woman. He served five years of a ten-year sentence but was reunited with his family some three years before your daughter vanished.

Imagine that you learn that nine years after your daughter vanished that this man was convicted of another crime, Breaking and Entering with the Intent to Commit a Felony. And the felony was directed against another young woman.

Imagine that you piece together a series of crimes against other young women where the perpetrator COULD HAVE BEEN your daughter’s adoptive father.

It wouldn’t take much from that point to imagine that just maybe this man had killed your daughter and disposed of her body. Law enforcement workers might even think it likely, but without some kind of proof, there would have been nothing they could have done.

Imagine you ask for help from all and sundry to get the word out and that you have age-progression portraits painted just in case she is out there, somewhere, and someone recognizes her. And you post them. And you network with Missing in Michigan, pay for a billboard along a highway, offer a reward.

And a few years pass. And keep imagining that you have lost your daughter twice; once when you give her up to adoption trusting that she would have a bright future, and the second time when you learned she was missing and investigators thought her likely dead. Still, you don’t give up; you start a facebook page calling out the man, challenging him to take a lie detector test, to own up to what you believe he has done to your daughter.

And all this imagining weighs on you until….

…Until, better than imagining, you learn that this man has been arrested for a murder, a murder in Virginia in 1980, when the adoptive father had returned to that state to fulfill a two-week Naval Reserve commitment.

And here is THAT story in the Holland Sentinel and and updated “supposing” account from Fox 17.

There is a lot more that will come out in the near future about that man, Dennis Bowman. Of course law enforcement is looking hard at the case, especially because now there might be some leverage to induce him to talk. Maybe. And you hope.

You, of course, are Cathy Terkanian, and this is your facebook page about the daughter you knew as Alexis Miranda Badger, renamed by Dennis Bowman and his wife, Brenda Joy Engweiler-Bowman, as Aundria Bowman.

Cathy Terkanian contacted me in 2013. I wasn’t able to offer much help, but I gave what I could during the next couple of years, in particular linking them with a wonderful private investigator. And Alexis/Aundria has long been up at our We Remember node on this website.

Cathy still hopes for her daughter to be found, alive and well. But she can imagine the alternative.

I hope you never have to imagine what has been the reality for Cathy. But perhaps you can imagine what it might be like for her to have answers. Pray for that. Work for that.

4 Comments »

November 25, 2019 — Witnesses Gord deVries and Courtney Davis

First up after Christopher McMilland was blueberry farmer Gord deVries. It was he who on May 8, 2002, found the badly burned body of an unknown murder victim, identified in 2015 first as Juan Cintron and subsequently as Roberto Caraballo. He attested that the body had not been there on his farm on May 7.

Note that this video again makes use of a graphic image of Roberto’s badly burned body. That was included as a referent to allow deVries to attest to what he saw.

Gord deVries testimony from David Schock on Vimeo.

Next up was Courtney Davis, who testified that defendant Dineane Ducharme had voluntarily elicited this specific statement: “We killed him.” It is that language that proves slippery to nail down.

Courtney Davis from David Schock on Vimeo.

This preliminary hearing was adjourned in order the allow the testimony of forensic pathologist Steven Cohle. That begins at 9 a.m. Dec. 3.

No Comments, Be the First! »