From David — A weblog (with full archive)

June 15, 2020 — Word has come that James Cleophus “Bubba” Nelson died in prison

The same source who shared that Harry Dean Keith died also shared that James Cleophus “Bubba” Nelson has died in prison.

Here is the account according the WHTC in Holland. And, while it makes no mention of his death here, is the OTIS sheet for his discharge:

He was a monster. After raping and killing Janet he went on to attack another woman some years later. As in Janet’s case, he used a belt to strangle her and, after raping her, left her for dead. When he was sentenced that woman drove from the south, Ohio maybe, and tried to get to the Grand Haven courtroom in time to see him come to justice. The roads were slippery and she was involved in a car crash. Still, she managed to get there, but too late to witness the sentencing. All that took great courage.

No Comments, Be the First! »

June 15, 2020 — Harry Dean Keith has died

Harry Dean Keith, involved in the 1979 murder of Janet Chandler, has died. We learned of his March 17 death from a reader. His testimony during the trial helped to advance the cases against the six who were charged. (Two pled and four were convicted.) You can view it here. There was plenty more that he knew that he took to the grave. It’s my assessment that he could have been much more helpful.

No Comments, Be the First! »

June 10, 2020 — Dennis Bowman pleads guilty to the 1980 murder of Kathleen O’Brien Doyle in Virginia

This from Amanda M. Howie, the director of communications at the Office of the Norfolk Commonwealth’s Attorney:

Dennis Lee Bowman (Date of Birth: 3/14/49) pleaded guilty in Norfolk Circuit Court this afternoon to 1 count of First Degree Murder, 1 count of Rape, and 1 count of Burglary. He was also sentenced today for the convictions to life in prison on both First Degree Murder and Rape and 20 years in prison for Burglary. Today’s convictions and total sentence (2 life terms plus 20 years in prison to be served consecutively) reflect the unwavering commitment of the Norfolk Police Department, Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS), and Norfolk Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office to pursue and secure justice – for nearly 40 years – for the woman Bowman killed and her many loved ones left to cherish her memory.

Kathleen O’Brien Doyle, 25-years-old, was found murdered in her Norfolk residence (9400 block of Granby Street) on September 11, 1980. She was the wife of a United States Navy pilot, who was deployed at the time of the homicide, and the daughter of a naval officer also serving in the United States Navy. Her murder was investigated for 39 years with the unyielding work of detectives, along with forensic evidence, culminating in the arrest of Bowman in November 2019 in Allegan County, Michigan, where he now lived. At that time, he was charged with 1 count of Second Degree Murder for Doyle’s murder and he remained in custody in Michigan until he was extradited to Norfolk in February 2020. On March 4, 2020, the Grand Jury in Norfolk Circuit Court indicted (via direct indictments presented by the Norfolk Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office) Bowman on 1 count of First Degree Murder, 1 count of Rape, and 1 count of Burglary. (Following these indictments, the Norfolk Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office nolle prossed the 1 count of Second Degree Murder in Norfolk General District Court.)

At today’s hearing, Deputy Commonwealth’s Attorney Philip G. Evans II spoke of how Kathleen’s father spent the rest of his life in regular communication with detectives to help ensure his daughter’s killer was identified and found. Sadly, he died in 2016, so today Mr. Evans told the Court he was reading “on his behalf, in his honor, and in her memory” words Kathleen’s father previously wrote while remembering her – “Though her pictures are all around me – on my desk and on the wall – I find it hard to describe Kathleen. My descriptive powers are simply inadequate to portray all her special qualities.”

Michigan has a detainer in place on Bowman and he will ultimately be returned to Allegan County (remaining in custody) where he was charged in May 2020 with charges related to the murder of his adopted daughter, Aundria Bowman, whom he adopted when he lived in Norfolk. Aundria Bowman was 14-years-old when she disappeared from the family’s home in March 1989.

The Norfolk Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office also appreciates the assistance of several public safety and criminal justice agencies in Michigan with the investigation and prosecution of this case.

He has already admitted to police that he killed his adopted daughter, referenced above as Aundria Bowman. The name her biological mother gave her was Alexis Miranda Badger.

She was Alexis. She is Alexis.

This cases hinges on DNA evidence, and thereby hangs a tale, not all oof which is mine to tell. But here is a description of the investigation and the outcome through the court paperwork.

No Comments, Be the First! »

May 21, 2020 — Michael Pagel admits his role in the killing of his wife, Renee

Another long-time-in-coming result…this time in the August 5, 2006 murder of Renee Pagel.

Her husband, Michael was arrested in February and charged in masterminding the murder of his wife.

Kent County Prosecutor Chris Becker and Sheriff Michelle Lajoye-Young, released a joint statement that read, in part: “It is gratifying to see him finally accept some responsibility for her murder for which he has been a suspect since the very beginning. The children of Michael and Renee were consulted before considering a plea offer, and we decided on this course of action based on their response and approval.”

A trial, they noted, would have been “extraordinarily difficult for this family.”

Michael Pagel alleges in his guilty plea that he convinced his brother to kill Renee, stabbing her to death in the couples’ Courtland Township home.

Investigators are not so sure about the brothers involvement. The statement continued:

“We were aware of the possibility that Michael Pagel may implicate others in the actual murder when he gave a factual basis for his plea. At this time, it is important to note that we are not aware of any independent evidence that can corroborate the statements Mr. Pagel made today.

“If Mr. Pagel wants to provide his version of events to the investigative team, they will listen to him, and follow up if he has any evidence to support his claim. This (prosecuting attorney) office and the Kent County Sheriff’s Department are committed to holding any person involved in Renee’s murder responsible for their actions. The statement of a defendant alone, with nothing more to support his version of events, is not enough by itself to charge anyone, with any crime. Without any supporting evidence, it is merely a statement of a man perhaps trying to save face in admitting his guilt in the murder of his wife, and should be treated as such.”

1 Comment »

May 20, 2020 — Dennis Bowman WILL face charges in his adopted daughter’s murder

Finding her remains was the first step to a finish. When police did that in February–excavating and revealing skeletal remains beneath a concrete slab– it was just a matter of time. Of course, 31 years has been a lot of time but a mother’s love and the determination of law enforcement were a combination that even this evil could not withstand.

And now Dennis Lee Bowman has been charged with murder, first-degree child abuse and mutilation of a body for allegedly killing his adopted daughter, known as Aundria Bowman. She was Alexis Miranda Badger to her birth mother, Cathy Terkanian. Here is the story of how she came to be Dennis Bowman’s adopted daughter.

And here is video of the announcement by Allegan Prosecuting Attorney Myrene Koch of the charges.

Dennis Bowman is in Virginia just now, the only suspect in the 1980 murder of Kathleen O’Brien Doyle, a 25-year-old daughter of a naval officer and wife of a deployed U.S. Navy pilot. He will be returned to Michigan to stand trial in Alexis’ murder.

Here is a report of the arrest from People Magazine.

She was Alexis. She is Alexis.

1 Comment »

April 27, 2020 — This morning

Really not much to share about crimes we’re covering. Beverly Anne Magliochetti (that is the name she was born with. She is aka Beverly McCallum) remains in an Italian jail awaiting extradition.

So, at least I can share the morning view over the river.

1 Comment »

March 6, 2020 — Mr. McMillan is sentenced

McMillan Sentencing from David Schock on Vimeo.

1 Comment »

March 4, 2020 — Sentencing tomorrow for Mr. McMillan

Tomorrow at 3 p.m. in Eaton County’s 56th Circult County, Judge Janice Cummingham presiding, Christopher Wayne McMillan will be sentenced for his part in the murder of Roberto Caraballo, May 7, 2002. He pled guilty last year and went on to testify against co-conspirator Dineane Ducharme. He likely will be called upon to testify against Beverly McMullen when she is returned from Rome in the (near??) future, courtesy of Federal Marshalls and the State Department. All that is part of the plea agreement that gives him only 15 years for his part in the crime. If his testimony is truthful, we understand that instead of striking Mr. Caraballo with a baseball bat–his duty as assigned by Beverly–he intentionally swung at a post in the basement and shattered the bat. He was not eager to kill and found himself in a nightmare. …And aligned with a remoreseless murderer.

I had been looking forward to being at this event to see this part of the work complete, but I will not be. I have been sidelined by another spinal fusion surgery. I can not even LIFT a camera, much less operate one. That’s for the next several months. My trusted associate Thom Bell WILL be there in my stead. I am grateful. He will make better pictures than I do. We will post them as soon as it’s possible.

No Comments, Be the First! »

February 13, 2020 — Beverly in custody!

Detective Sergeant Josh Ivey of the Eaton County Sheriff’s department told me last month that he was sure Beverly McCallum–wanted for the 2002 murder and mutilation of her husband, Roberto Caraballo–would be found. It was just a matter of time. “They don’t get away often,” he said.

He and I agreed, I taking my cue from the idea that there is nothing hidden that shall not be made known. The whereabouts of an accused killer would fall into that realm. It seemed obvious to both of us that that she would slip up and be found.

She did and she was. Here’s today’s Detroit Free Press article on the same.

She has been on the run with her teenaged son since she vanished from Pakistan. There was even a report that she had made it as far as South America. But no. Rome.

There are so many stories that will come out as she is brought back to face justice. Yes, our film Jack in the Box and this web played a significant role, but it’s the dogged determination of law enforcers who had led this case the Beverly’s apprehension and the so-far prosecution of Christopher McMillan (who pled guilty) and the binding over to face charges of first-degree murder for Beverly’s daughter Dineane Ducharme.

That part of the story starts with a phone call that Detective Bob Donker, now retired from the Ottawa County Sheriff’s Department, received in 2015.

And it’s there I’ll leave it for now. While I may know some things, just because I may be aware does mean that it’s mine to tell. There is one thing that is mine to tell: there have been so many people praying for justice in this case. So many. I believe we have just witnessed another miracle.

1 Comment »

February 6, 2020 — An arrest in the murder of Renee Pagel

Thirteen years after her murder, Renee Pagel’s husband, Michael James Pagel, has been charged with the crime. This according to WOODTV.

One of the people cited in the story is Chris Crandle, Renee’s good friend and untiring advocate for revealing the killer. Chris has remained sure right from the start that it was Michael who was responsible for Renee’s stabbing death in her home in Courtland Township, Kent County, MI, on August 5, 2006. But assurance and proof are two different things. It seems that at last they have come together. Everyone should have such a friend. Thank you, Chris. Thank you. And thank you law enforcement and Kent County Prosecutor Chris Becker for pressing on. Now it begins to play out.

Two days and two stunning revelations in delayed-justice cases.

No Comments, Be the First! »